EDIT:
This whole back and forth reminds me about the fight I had with Maou about the importance of an arrangement vs. the actual songwriting. In this case, I would say Souretsu's songwriting is nothing special but its KZK arrangement is.
For more on Souretsu:
You know, I think we discussed the meaning of Souretsu before. I think Frecklegirl says it is either about 1) an abortion or 2) the metaphorical death and rebirth of creativity
So, the KZK album version is obviously 2). And the live version is obviously 1). They are two interpretations of a song that are so different you can't even compare them.
That is why it is completely pointless to say that one is better than the other. I honestly believe that they are NOT even two version of the same song.
That being said, comparing the two songs is not relevant to this discussion.
|