New Game: Ringo's "rare" compositions

[Osiris12345]

Nice idea for a H&H thread.

Suberidai = 9
Private = 4
Memai = 6 (-1)
Remote Controller = 6 (-1)
Cappuccino = 7
Mokuren no Cream = 7
Shampoo = 8
Aozora = 8
Rinne Highlight = 5 (-1)
Toki ga Bousou Suru = 9 (-1)
Sigma = 5
17 = 7
Shoujo Robot = 8
Ikenai Ko = 6
Nippon ni Umarete = 9
Fukou Jiman = 9
So Cold = 7
Fukurande Kichatta = 7
Hai Hai = 7
Kougousei = 2 (-1)
Mayonaka wa Junketsu = 8
Aisaika no Choshoku = 10 (+1)
Ichijiku no Hana = 8
Ringo Catalogue = 7
Kokoro = 8
Rakujitsu = 8
Amagasa = 5
Kachuu no Otoko = 7
Hiyori-Hime = 5
Ariamaru Tomi = 8

[ShinjiPG]

Suberidai = 9
Private = 4
Memai = 6
Remote Controller = 6
Cappuccino = 7
Mokuren no Cream = 7
Shampoo = 8
Aozora = 8
Rinne Highlight = 4 (-1)
Toki ga Bousou Suru = 9
Sigma = 5
17 = 7
Shoujo Robot = 8
Ikenai Ko = 6
Nippon ni Umarete = 9
Fukou Jiman = 9
So Cold = 7
Fukurande Kichatta = 7
Hai Hai = 7
Kougousei = 3 (+1)
Mayonaka wa Junketsu = 8
Aisaika no Choshoku = 10
Ichijiku no Hana = 8
Ringo Catalogue = 7
Kokoro = 8
Rakujitsu = 8
Amagasa = 4 (-1)
Kachuu no Otoko = 6 (-1)
Hiyori-Hime = 4 (-1)
Ariamaru Tomi = 7 (-1)

Why is "Mellow" out?

[Ringo~Bingo]

Suberidai = 9
Private = 4
Memai = 6
Remote Controller = 6
Cappuccino = 7
Mokuren no Cream = 6 (-1)
Shampoo = 8
Aozora = 8
Rinne Highlight = 4
Toki ga Bousou Suru = 9
Sigma = 4 (-1)
17 = 7
Shoujo Robot = 9 (+1)
Ikenai Ko = 6
Nippon ni Umarete = 9
Fukou Jiman = 8 (-1)
So Cold = 7
Fukurande Kichatta = 6 (-1)
Hai Hai = 7
Kougousei = 3
Mayonaka wa Junketsu = 8
Aisaika no Choshoku = 10
Ichijiku no Hana = 8
Ringo Catalogue = 7
Kokoro = 7 (-1)
Rakujitsu = 8
Amagasa = 4
Kachuu no Otoko = 6
Hiyori-Hime = 4
Ariamaru Tomi = 7

[merman]

Suberidai = 9
Private = 4
Memai = 5 (-1)
Remote Controller = 6
Cappuccino = 7
Mokuren no Cream = 5 (-1)
Shampoo = 8
Aozora = 8
Rinne Highlight = 3 (-1)
Toki ga Bousou Suru = 9
Sigma = 4
17 = 6 (-1)
Shoujo Robot = 9
Ikenai Ko = 6
Nippon ni Umarete = 9
Fukou Jiman = 8
So Cold = 7
Fukurande Kichatta = 6
Hai Hai = 7
Kougousei = 2 (-1)
Mayonaka wa Junketsu = 8
Aisaika no Choshoku = 10
Ichijiku no Hana = 8
Ringo Catalogue = 8 (+1)
Kokoro = 7 (-1)
Rakujitsu = 8
Amagasa = 4
Kachuu no Otoko = 6
Hiyori-Hime = 4
Ariamaru Tomi = 7

[so_cold]

Felt like voting against the A-sides this time. And actually the song that played in my head when I read this list was Shampoo...

Suberidai = 9
Private = 3 (-1)
Memai = 5
Remote Controller = 6
Cappuccino = 7
Mokuren no Cream = 5
Shampoo = 9 (+1)
Aozora = 8
Rinne Highlight = 3
Toki ga Bousou Suru = 9
Sigma = 4
17 = 6
Shoujo Robot = 9
Ikenai Ko = 6
Nippon ni Umarete = 9
Fukou Jiman = 8
So Cold = 7
Fukurande Kichatta = 6
Hai Hai = 7
Kougousei = 2
Mayonaka wa Junketsu = 7 (-1)
Aisaika no Choshoku = 10
Ichijiku no Hana = 8
Ringo Catalogue = 8
Kokoro = 7
Rakujitsu = 8
Amagasa = 3 (-1)
Kachuu no Otoko = 6
Hiyori-Hime = 3 (-1)
Ariamaru Tomi = 6 (-1)

[kuro_neko]

iunno, I just feel like this list is really uneven when you consider the songs competing against each other. technically mayonaka is an a-side, even though it was never on an album, so I don't know if it is considered really rare. WtH was considered a "best album" which is still a major album....I guess what I find difficult is the length of the list, when I look at all of them I just kind of cramp up and am like AHHH WHAT DO I DOOOOO!? WHO DO I PICK!? I guess I'll wait until the list pares down a little bit to vote...

[Glathannus]

Originally Posted by ShinjiPG

Why is "Mellow" out?

Because it's not one of Shiina Ringo's own compositions.

Now in response to kuro_neko...
Choosing which tracks you want to take away points from, is the most difficult part of this whole game. Especially when you can't just spam all of the same choices everytime. It forces me to think about my choices for more than just a minute or two. After we've killed off our first 5-10 tracks, this game is going to get nasty.

Suberidai = 9
Private = 3
Memai = 5
Remote Controller = 6
Cappuccino = 7
Mokuren no Cream = 4 (-1)
Shampoo = 9
Aozora = 9 (+1)
Rinne Highlight = 3
Toki ga Bousou Suru = 9
Sigma = 4
17 = 6
Shoujo Robot = 9
Ikenai Ko = 6
Nippon ni Umarete = 9
Fukou Jiman = 8
So Cold = 7
Fukurande Kichatta = 5 (-1)
Hai Hai = 6 (-1)
Kougousei = 2
Mayonaka wa Junketsu = 7
Aisaika no Choshoku = 10
Ichijiku no Hana = 8
Ringo Catalogue = 8
Kokoro = 7
Rakujitsu = 7 (-1)
Amagasa = 3
Kachuu no Otoko = 5 (-1)
Hiyori-Hime = 3
Ariamaru Tomi = 6

I've got a new rule that will make this game more interesting.
You can't kill more than one track per turn.

[mizer_unmei]

Suberidai = 9
Private = 3
Memai = 5
Remote Controller = 6
Cappuccino = 7
Mokuren no Cream = 4
Shampoo = 9
Aozora = 9
Rinne Highlight = 3
Toki ga Bousou Suru = 9
Sigma = 3 (-1)
17 = 6
Shoujo Robot = 9
Ikenai Ko = 6
Nippon ni Umarete = 9
Fukou Jiman = 7 (-1)
So Cold = 6 (-1)
Fukurande Kichatta = 6 (+1)
Hai Hai = 6
Kougousei = 2
Mayonaka wa Junketsu = 7
Aisaika no Choshoku = 10
Ichijiku no Hana = 7 (-1)
Ringo Catalogue = 7 (-1)
Kokoro = 7
Rakujitsu = 7
Amagasa = 3
Kachuu no Otoko = 5
Hiyori-Hime = 3
Ariamaru Tomi = 6

[Tokyo Jihad]

Mizer's votes makes me very sad

[frecklegirl]

Suberidai = 9
Private = 3
Memai = 5
Remote Controller = 6
Cappuccino = 7
Mokuren no Cream = 4
Shampoo = 9
Aozora = 9
Rinne Highlight = 3
Toki ga Bousou Suru = 9
Sigma = 3
17 = 6
Shoujo Robot = 9
Ikenai Ko = 6
Nippon ni Umarete = 9
Fukou Jiman = 6 (-1)
So Cold = 5 (-1)
Fukurande Kichatta = 5 (-1)
Hai Hai = 5 (-1)
Kougousei = 1 (-1)
Mayonaka wa Junketsu = 7
Aisaika no Choshoku = 11 (+1)
Ichijiku no Hana = 7
Ringo Catalogue = 7
Kokoro = 7
Rakujitsu = 7
Amagasa = 3
Kachuu no Otoko = 5
Hiyori-Hime = 3
Ariamaru Tomi = 6