OSCA PV Plagiarism

[Jonny]

Uh when and by and for whom was OP PV made?

[Fukurou]

1) Can't it possibly be an homage instead of a thievery ?

2) Possibly the director's fault if they didn't see this clip.

3) Admitting they steal it : so what, does that makes their music bad now ?
Sure i would be a little disapointed, but heh, not everyones perfect, and here it's not the worst drama (stealing music from other band would be).
And sometimes we have to learn to let go about some flaw, because if we judge people's work on their flaws, it's like...i don't know, like we can't watch any Schwarzenneger movie because of what he became now ?
For me, since it doesn't come to music, wich is the real important point for them, it's still ok.

Originally Posted by Canto

Shiina's superpower was totally washed down into the toilet some time last year.

Hi, you're on my "to kill" list starting from today.
Bye.

[justriiingo]

Originally Posted by Fukurou

Hi, you're on my "to kill" list starting from today.
Bye.

Ooo? Am I on that list too? Probably.

[Lena-chan]

I'm sure if TJ is trying to pay homage with this PV
Killer tune PV will be a homage too...
but it'll depend on how SR is being on the 3rd phase o.o
and Fukurou... you're so passionate.

[Fukurou]

I'm...not sure if that was compliment, haha

And yes, if what follows for this albums is still "ripoffs", then we can think "homages".

Originally Posted by justriiingo

Ooo? Am I on that list too? Probably.

It depends.
What do you think of Shiina lately ?
*prepares pen and list*

[Tokyo Jihad]

Guys, who really cares its a "borrowed" idea or what? No one was exactly going kermit.gif about the videos brilliance and "z0mg no ones done this before, theys the best!"

Its not a big deal either way, coincidence or knowingly pinching the idea.

[justriiingo]

Originally Posted by Tokyo Jihad

Guys, who really cares its a "borrowed" idea or what? No one was exactly going kermit.gif about the videos brilliance and "z0mg no ones done this before, theys the best!"

Er. Please go re-read the New Single thread. My impression was that too many people liked the PV.

[Tokyo Jihad]

I recall people liking the song, being so-so about the vid (even less taking out "panties")

My point is, its not like we see a music video from 95 thats shot for shot the videos for Honnou or Tsumi to Batsu or even Meisai. I don't think anyones so heartbroken about this, and some might be making a bigger deal about this than it really warrants.

and GIBS is still waay more of a rip-off >=|

[justriiingo]

I thought Gibs and Yami ni Furu Ame looked like Luna Sea vids.

[ShadyNook]

Just think of it as the cultural norm of taking something that already exists and then making it better, like what happened to televisions and automobiles.